•5 min read•By Tiago Marques

My Teacher Got Upset About My Chair

AccordionPostureMusicPractice

I showed up to a lesson once with my accordion, my sheet music on my desk, and an office chair on wheels. Nothing unusual, or so I thought.

My teacher took one look at the setup and repeated the same advice she had given me before. She wasn’t angry in a shouting way—but she was firm. The kind of firm that makes you realize you’ve been doing something wrong without quite understanding what.

“You can’t practice on that”, she said, pointing at the chair. “No wheels, stable base. You should use a proper stool.” Then she looked at the sheet music flat on my desk. “And please use a music stand. You’re constantly looking down at the desk and it affects you more than you think.”

I remember thinking to myself, the first time she told me this: ok, you’re right about the music stand, but the chair? Really?

I’d been so focused on fingering, bellows control, phrasing. The chair felt like furniture. Background. Surely what mattered was what I did with my hands. I even had bought that particular chair because it had retractable armrests!

But she repeated the same advice the next lesson. And the second time she pointed it out, I knew I was being lazy, and finding excuses, basically.

Given that my lessons are currently virtual, and since I use my computer for all sorts of music-related tasks (controlling the metronome, adjusting scores, logging my practice sessions, etc.), I had bought a pedal to switch music pages on my screen. My office is very small, so even though I have a music stand, I deliberately don’t incorporate it into my setup, because I don’t have space near the desk. But out of laziness, I didn’t even plug that pedal in, and kept putting the sheets flat on my desk. I sometimes use the music stand when I practice outside of my office, but that’s not the case during lessons.

Secondly, I juggle constantly between office work, and picking up the accordion as soon as I have some free time. This means constantly switching between sitting on an office chair and an accordion stool is not necessarily practical. My excuse was immediately dismissed by my teacher, because I don’t switch contexts for at least one hour, the time of the lesson, so if I really cared, I would have prepared in advance.

The pattern I didn’t see

A few years prior, I studied with another teacher—Liliana Aparício—who had just finished her master’s research on exactly this topic: posture, pain, and perceived effort in accordion students. Her thesis studied 21 young accordionists and found clear connections between playing setup, asymmetric body load, and musculoskeletal pain.

The findings weren’t surprising to her. She’d seen the pattern for years. The accordion is heavy, asymmetric, and you hold the same position for an hour at a time. If you add an unstable seat to that, your spine has to compensate for every micro-wobble on top of managing the instrument.

That’s when my current teacher’s reaction started to make sense. She wasn’t being picky. She was trying to stop me from building a habit that would hurt me later.

Most accordion teachers have either dealt with back pain themselves or watched students develop it. They know the damage builds up slowly—you don’t notice anything for months, maybe years, and then one day you can’t ignore it anymore. That’s why they react before you feel anything wrong. By the time you feel it, the habit is deep.

It’s not only about your back

My teacher made another point that stuck with me: posture isn’t only about pain prevention—it directly affects your technique.

When you bend forward, your elbow and wrist automatically adjust to compensate. Your hand ends up wherever it lands, rather than where you deliberately place it. You stop paying attention to how your fingers approach the keyboard because your whole arm has already made the decision for you.

Leaning backwards on a reclinable chair is even worse. It feels comfortable, but that’s the trap—it enables a kind of body laziness where your core disengages entirely. You’re not sitting anymore; you’re sinking. And your arms have to reach forward awkwardly to find the keys.

Sitting upright forces you to stay conscious of your hand position. It’s harder at first, but that’s the point—the difficulty is the feedback that tells you you’re doing it right.

<img src=“/img/vanity-stool.jpg” alt=“The stool under my wife’s vanity desk” style=“float: right; max-width: 180px; margin: 0 0 1rem 1.5rem; border-radius: 8px;” />

I ended up using a simple wooden stool that was sitting under my wife’s vanity desk. No back support, no wheels, no tilt—just a flat, stable surface at the right height. Sometimes the solution is already in your house; you don’t need a shopping spree. It feels awkward—I have to actually sit properly, engaging my core, keeping my spine aligned. It’s too early to report results, but at least I’m not fighting the chair anymore.

Regarding the page turning pedal, I still need to get used to it. I need to find a comfortable workflow that makes me more productive using the computer screen, without having to fight it. Also, I can use the music stand when I practice outside of my office, and I can certainly do that more often, namely on weekends.

Morale of the story: no excuses. Just make things work, and protect your body.


That lesson pushed me to change more than my chair—it changed how I thought about training my body. More on that in Part 2.


This post is part of the series Why Accordion Posture Is Not Optional.

Reference: Aparício, L. (2014). Postura, dor e perceção de esforço na aprendizagem do acordeão [Master’s thesis]. Available at Academia.edu.